What Is SAP Private Cloud
SAP Private Cloud, formerly known as RISE with SAP, is an all-in-one cloud ERP subscription offering that bundles SAP S/4HANA software, cloud infrastructure, and managed services under a single contract.
It provides CIOs and CTOs a “one-stop” private cloud edition of SAP’s flagship ERP, with the promise of simplified transformation and a shift from upfront licenses to a subscription model.
However, while SAP Private Cloud can accelerate cloud adoption, enterprise IT leaders must carefully weigh its licensing model and cost structure to avoid vendor lock-in and unexpected cost escalations.
Read SAP RISE Licensing Models: Subscription Pricing, Bundles, and Best Practices.
Considering RISE with SAP / SAP ERP Private Cloud?
Before you commit, download this white paper to avoid costly licensing mistakes, reduce risk, and make the right cloud decision for your business.
👉 [Download here]
Understanding SAP Private Cloud (Former RISE with SAP)
SAP Private Cloud (the artist formerly known as RISE with SAP) is SAP’s subscription-based cloud ERP package aimed at moving customers from on-premise SAP ERP (ECC or SAP S/4HANA) into a cloud-managed environment.
Introduced in 2021 as “RISE with SAP,” this offering was positioned as a concierge service to guide digital transformation, essentially a bundle of SAP S/4HANA Cloud (private edition) along with cloud hosting and various SAP tools, all delivered via one contract with SAP.
In mid-2025, SAP rebranded parts of RISE with SAP under the “SAP Cloud ERP, Private Edition” name, adjusting package tiers and inclusions.
The core idea remained: SAP acts as the single provider for your ERP software and the underlying cloud infrastructure and services, reducing multi-vendor complexity.
For context, SAP S/4HANA Cloud comes in two flavors – public (multi-tenant SaaS) and private (single-tenant) editions.
The private cloud edition gives each customer their own isolated S/4HANA instance with full control over upgrade timing and customization (closely resembling a traditional dedicated ERP environment).
In contrast, the public cloud edition is a shared SaaS environment with standardized processes and limited customization.
SAP Private Cloud leverages the private edition to offer the best of both worlds: the flexibility of on-premise systems (you can retain custom code and unique configurations) combined with the outsourced convenience of cloud.
SAP handles infrastructure, base technical management, and system updates under agreed service levels.
Key Components of the SAP Private Cloud Package
A subscription to SAP’s Private Cloud (RISE) package typically includes several integrated components designed to cover end-to-end needs:
- SAP S/4HANA Cloud (Private Edition) – The core ERP software, delivering the full SAP S/4HANA functionality (financials, logistics, HR, etc.) in a single-tenant cloud deployment. This is essentially the digital core of your business processes, but running on SAP’s cloud services or hyperscaler infrastructure instead of your own data center.
- Cloud Infrastructure & Technical Management – SAP provides hosting as part of the subscription. In practice, SAP usually arranges the infrastructure through a hyperscaler partner (e.g., Azure, AWS, GCP) or SAP’s own data centers, but the costs and coordination are bundled into your SAP contract. SAP manages base system admin tasks, patching, and upgrades per agreed SLAs, letting your IT team focus more on business functionality than on hardware.
- SAP Basis Support & Maintenance – The Private Cloud subscription includes SAP’s support services for the environment. This covers technical monitoring, disaster recovery, and the SAP Enterprise Support (or equivalent) for the S/4HANA software. You no longer pay separate annual maintenance on licenses – it’s wrapped into the subscription fee, with SAP ensuring your system is up-to-date and supported.
- Value-Added SAP Tools & Services – Depending on the package tier, additional SAP products and services are bundled. For example, earlier RISE packages included tools like SAP Signavio (process analysis), SAP Business Technology Platform (BTP) credits for extensions, and SAP Business Network starter packages. Higher tiers offered more extras – e.g., Premium Plus (now discontinued) had advanced analytics (SAP Analytics Cloud), sustainability management tools, and even SAP’s new AI assistant (SAP Joule) built in. These bundled tools aim to provide a jump-start on process improvements and innovation out of the box.
- One Agreement, One Throat to Choke – A key selling point for CIOs is that SAP Private Cloud consolidates many elements (licenses, hosting, support) into a single contract and invoice. Rather than negotiating separately with a cloud vendor, a hardware provider, a support partner, etc., you deal only with SAP for all these aspects. In theory, this simplifies vendor management and accountability – SAP is solely responsible for your ERP’s uptime and performance as per the contract.
It’s important to note that the exact contents of the package can vary based on what you negotiate.
SAP has offered tiered bundles historically (e.g., Base vs. Premium), and as of 2025, the “Private” package can be further augmented with optional add-ons (for AI, advanced features, etc.).
Always clarify which components are included in your subscription and which might cost extra, as this bundling can obscure the true cost of each component.
Licensing Model: Full User Equivalents (FUE)
Moving to SAP’s Private Cloud changes not only how you pay (opex subscription vs. capital license purchase), but also how user licenses are counted.
SAP uses the concept of Full User Equivalents (FUE) to measure the subscription entitlement.
Instead of buying named user licenses of different types as in traditional SAP, you estimate how many “user equivalents” your organization needs, and you subscribe to that number of FUEs, which cover all your users.
Each user in your system is categorized (by level of usage) and contributes a fraction of an FUE. For example, a casual self-service employee who just submits timesheets or views pay stubs has a light footprint.
In contrast, a professional power-user in finance or supply chain has a heavy usage profile. SAP defines these roughly as:
| User Category | FUE Conversion (Users per 1 FUE) |
|---|---|
| Self-Service User (ESS/light) | 30 users = 1 FUE (each user = 0.033 FUE) |
| Core/Functional User (mid-level) | 5 users = 1 FUE (each user = 0.2 FUE) |
| Advanced/Professional User | 1 user = 1 FUE (each user = 1.0 FUE) |
| Developer/Technical User | 2 users = 1 FUE (each user = 0.5 FUE) |
In practical terms, this means you don’t pay for 100 named users if, say, most of them are light users – those might equate to just a handful of FUEs. For instance, 30 self-service employees count as only 1 FUE, whereas one power user = 1 FUE.
This weighting reflects the relative compute/functional load each user type puts on the system. The FUE approach can be cost-efficient if you have lots of occasional users.
But it also requires careful analysis: you must classify your users accurately to size the contract right.
Overestimating FUEs wastes money; underestimating can lead to compliance issues (since SAP will expect you to true-up if more users or heavier use categories emerge during your subscription).
SAP typically sets minimum FUE commitments for a Private Cloud deal (e.g., a floor number of FUEs regardless of actual users). So even if you start with a small user count, you might have to subscribe to a minimum bundle size.
Understanding the FUE makeup of your user base is critical before signing – e.g., if you have 1000 employees but only 100 are heavy users and 900 are self-service, your FUE might be calculated roughly as 100 (advanced) + 900/30 (self-service) ≈ , 130 FUE, not 1000.
This licensing model is quite different from the old world of named user licenses, and procurement teams should run careful scenarios to validate SAP’s FUE proposal.
Pricing Structure and Real-World Cost Examples
SAP Private Cloud subscriptions are priced based on the number of FUEs and the package/tier of services included. The pricing model is generally tiered – the more FUEs (users) you commit to, the lower the per-unit cost.
SAP’s list prices can be steep for small customers, but volume discounts kick in aggressively at higher user counts. For example, in one 2024 price list for Europe, a very small deployment (under ~135 FUE) carried a list price around €716 per user per month, whereas a mid-sized 5,000 user deal might be about €64 per user/month, and a very large 10,000+ user deployment could drop closer to €47 or even €35 per user/month.
Thanks to the tiered discounts, it can cost less to buy more: one IT asset management study found that purchasing ~6,000 users was cheaper in total cost than buying 5,000 users, because crossing a discount tier dramatically lowered the unit price.
The takeaway is that SAP’s cloud pricing curve is non-linear – savvy negotiators will aim to hit the next volume tier to reduce average cost.
To illustrate, below is an indicative price tier table (example list prices, per FUE, in EUR):
| FUE Volume (Subscription Size) | Approx. List Price per FUE/month* |
|---|---|
| Small Deal (up to ~135 FUE) | ~€716 per FUE/month |
| Mid-sized (~5,000 FUE) | ~€64 per FUE/month |
| Large (~6,000 – 12,000 FUE) | ~€47 per FUE/month |
| Very Large (25,000+ FUE) | ~€35 or less per FUE/month |
Actual prices vary by region and deal; enterprise discounts can lower these figures. The trend shown is steep volume discounting.
In terms of total cost of ownership, SAP often positions Private Cloud as financially attractive compared to on-premise.
For example, consider an organization needing 10,000 users: SAP might show that a 5-year Private Cloud subscription (including infrastructure) comes out slightly cheaper than buying perpetual licenses + 5 years of hardware and support.
One real-world scenario estimated ~€42.5 million over 10 years for SAP Private Cloud versus ~€43.8 million for on-prem (software + hardware), highlighting a nominal savings by going cloud. SAP’s sales teams will emphasize these comparisons, but CIOs should scrutinize the assumptions.
Key points to watch: the cloud subscription in that comparison assumed no price increases for 10 years (an unlikely scenario), and it locked the customer into SAP’s ecosystem entirely.
In reality, SAP (like any vendor) can raise subscription fees at renewal, and usage of additional services (like extra storage, integrations, or AI features) may drive costs above initial estimates.
Contract length is another cost factor. SAP Private Cloud deals are typically multi-year commitments (3, 5, or even 7 years).
The longer the term and the larger the user count, the more negotiating leverage you may have on unit price, but a long commitment also means you’re betting on SAP’s platform for that duration with limited exit options.
Make sure the subscription term aligns with your company’s strategy and that you’re comfortable with the spend profile (often millions per year for large enterprises).
Many contracts include yearly escalators (e.g., a 5% per year price increase) or at least the possibility of an increase upon renewal. Try to negotiate caps on such increases or lock in prices for as long as possible, because the initial “sweet” pricing can sour later if unchecked.
Risks and Key Considerations
Adopting SAP’s all-in-one Private Cloud offering comes with significant implications beyond just a technical upgrade.
CIOs and procurement heads should weigh the following considerations and potential risks:
- Vendor Lock-In: Moving to SAP Private Cloud means SAP becomes your cloud provider, application provider, and support provider in one. While this simplifies accountability, it also intensifies lock-in. It’s not easy to disentangle yourself from SAP’s ecosystem once you’re in – for example, if you wanted later to switch your infrastructure to a different provider or move to a different ERP, you may find contractual and data-extraction hurdles. You are committing to SAP’s roadmap (and whims) for the duration. Ensure you have an exit strategy in the contract (e.g., provisions for data export, penalties for early termination, etc.), and go in with eyes open that switching costs will be high if you change course.
- Bundling Complexity (All-or-Nothing): The bundling of software, infrastructure, and services means you get a lot in the package, but not all components may be useful to your business. For instance, you might be paying for SAP Signavio or SAP Analytics Cloud included in the bundle even if you already use alternative solutions or don’t need them initially. The cost is “built in” regardless. This can lead to overpaying for shelfware. Unfortunately, SAP often provides limited flexibility to remove or swap components; the bundle is sold as a value package. When evaluating offers, insist on transparency: have SAP itemize the bundle value (even if they won’t price each item separately) so you can see what you’re paying for. If certain bundled services are redundant for you, negotiate to opt out or get credits for them – even if not fully possible, raising the issue can lead to extra discounts or concessions elsewhere.
- Higher Cost for Convenience: Many organizations find that SAP’s managed cloud convenience comes at a premium. You are essentially outsourcing infrastructure management to SAP (who, in turn, likely outsources it to hyperscalers but adds a margin). That margin can be significant. Some customers have analyzed the infrastructure portion of RISE/Private Cloud fees and discovered they could run equivalent workloads directly on AWS/Azure for noticeably less. The trade-off is you’d then have to manage it or use a third-party provider. Thus, consider whether the premium you pay SAP for “one throat to choke” support is worth it. In some cases, it may be justified (mission-critical support, internal staff limitations); in others, a DIY approach with separate license and cloud contracts could save money. Benchmark the pricing: break down SAP’s quote into software vs infrastructure vs services, and compare each to market rates.
- Complex Sizing and Compliance: The FUE model introduces complexity in sizing your needs. If your user counts or usage patterns grow over time (which is likely as businesses change), you might exceed your subscribed FUEs. Unlike traditional perpetual licensing, where you might only true-up at support renewal or an audit, in the subscription world, SAP will expect you to adjust (and pay for) the overage relatively quickly. Mid-term changes (like an acquisition adding 500 new employees to the system) can increase costs sharply. It’s critical to include flexibility in the contract for growth – for example, predefined pricing for adding FUEs later, or a buffer of extra FUE capacity. Also, maintain governance on user licensing internally: monitor how many users of each type you have using the system, to avoid surprises. Non-compliance in a cloud model could result in hefty unforeseen charges or service limitations.
- Future Technology Add-Ons: When RISE with SAP was first marketed, it bundled a wide array of tools (even a generous amount of SAP’s AI/ML and analytics capabilities at the highest tier). Now, after the 2025 rebranding, SAP has made some of these advanced features optional add-ons. Notably, generative AI (SAP “Joule”) and advanced sustainability or data analytics features might cost extra on top of your base subscription. SAP is eager to monetize new innovations separately. This means that to get cutting-edge capabilities in the future, you should be prepared for add-on subscriptions or consumption-based fees (for example, AI services might be metered by usage). CIOs should budget for these potential costs and negotiate early access or pilot amounts in the contract if those technologies are important to their roadmap. Don’t assume “we’ll automatically get all the new toys” – clarify what is included now and how new services will be priced.
- Timeline and Migration Effort: Subscribing to SAP Private Cloud doesn’t magically eliminate the effort of migrating to S/4HANA. Companies must still execute a migration project (whether a system conversion of ECC to S/4, or a fresh implementation). The RISE program does include some tools and services to help (like readiness checks, process discovery workshops, and perhaps a one-time technical migration service from SAP or a partner). But much of the heavy lifting – data migration, testing, change management – remains your responsibility. Be careful of aggressive timelines; SAP may push for quick cloud moves (especially with the looming 2027 end-of-mainstream-support for ECC). Ensure you have a realistic plan and possibly negotiate migration assistance into the contract (e.g., some free consulting hours, or reduced fees during the transition period when you might be double-running old and new systems). Also, consider the contractual linkage with existing licenses: SAP often provides incentives (like conversion credits or the right to terminate maintenance on old systems) when you sign a RISE deal. Use these to reduce overlap costs, but double-check the terms (for example, once you convert your on-prem licenses to cloud, you may forfeit rights to revert back).
In summary, SAP Private Cloud can deliver a streamlined path to cloud ERP, but the convenience comes with trade-offs in cost flexibility and autonomy.
Diligent planning and negotiation are required to make it a success on both technical and commercial fronts.
Read SAP RISE FUE Calculation for Contract Negotiation.
Recommendations
In light of the above, here are some practical advice and strategies for CIOs, CTOs, and procurement leaders considering or negotiating SAP Private Cloud (RISE with SAP) contracts:
- Assess Actual Needs vs. Bundle: Take an inventory of what your organization truly needs in terms of ERP functionality and surrounding tools. Use that to challenge SAP’s bundled offering – if the package includes components you won’t use, raise it. Aim to remove them or secure a better price. Don’t simply accept the one-size bundle without question.
- Insist on Transparency: During negotiations, ask SAP for a detailed breakdown of costs (software vs infrastructure vs services). While they may not divulge everything, even a ballpark split helps you understand where the money is going. Push for clarity on FUE calculations, including modules, and any limits (like storage, user count, etc.). The more you understand the pricing model, the better you can optimize it.
- Leverage Volume Tiers: Use SAP’s tiered pricing to your advantage. If you’re near a user count threshold that would significantly drop the per-user cost, consider negotiating a slightly higher FUE count (or longer term) to unlock a better discount. It could lower your overall spend. SAP sales reps are often willing to cut a deal if you commit to a bigger size – just ensure it’s needed or provides breathing room for growth.
- Secure Price Protections: Cloud subscriptions can be a “Trojan horse” for future price hikes. Negotiate caps on annual increases (e.g., no more than CPI or a single-digit % per year) and try to lock renewal options at pre-agreed rates. If you’re signing a 5-year term, attempt to fix the price for at least that term with no increases. Also clarify treatment of new add-ons – e.g,. if you adopt an SAP AI service in year 3, can you get preferential rates? Get these in writing.
- Mind the Contract Details: Scrutinize the contract for flexibility. Aim for rights to reduce usage or swap components if business needs change (even if SAP’s standard terms don’t allow much, you can negotiate custom clauses). Include exit provisions: what happens at the end of the term or if you choose to leave SAP Private Cloud? Ensure you won’t be stranded without access to your data or facing hefty penalties. Having an “off-ramp” clause gives you leverage and peace of mind.
- Utilize Conversion Incentives: If you have significant existing SAP investment (perpetual licenses on maintenance), work with SAP to apply credits or transition discounts into the Private Cloud deal. SAP often offers incentives like “RISE credits” to offset double-paying maintenance during migration, or favorable conversion ratios for your licenses. Make sure these are maximized – they can substantially lower the total cost of moving to the cloud if negotiated well.
- Benchmark Against Alternatives: Before you sign, compare the RISE/Private Cloud proposal with alternative approaches. For example, pricing out “bringing your own license” to a hyperscaler + third-party support, or upgrading on-prem and staying on traditional support for a few more years. Even if you intend to go cloud, having these benchmarks gives you negotiation ammunition. If SAP knows you’re considering staying on ECC or moving to AWS directly, they may improve their offer to dissuade you.
- Plan for Implementation (Don’t Underestimate Effort): Ensure that a solid project plan and resources back your move to SAP Private Cloud. The subscription starts the clock on your expenses, so align the contract start with when you can begin using the product productively. Negotiate a ramp-up period (e.g., lower fees in the first 6-12 months) if you know it will take time to migrate users onto the new system. SAP might agree to a stepped approach rather than full billing from day one.
- Stay Informed on SAP’s Roadmap: Keep an eye on SAP’s product strategy for S/4HANA Cloud. With the 2025 packaging changes (e.g., AI now unbundled), SAP’s offerings will continue to evolve. Make it a point to get most-favored treatment – e.g. if SAP releases a new feature or service that could benefit you, have language in the contract that you can access a trial or negotiate it into your package. Staying current on SAP announcements (like at Sapphire or TechEd conferences) will allow you to anticipate changes that could affect your contract or future costs.
- Engage Experts or Advisors: Finally, don’t go it alone in complex SAP negotiations. Involve licensing experts or third-party advisors who have experience with RISE/SAP Private Cloud deals. They can provide benchmark data (e.g., “What % discount off list is reasonable for a deal of our size?”) and help spot red flags in terms. The cost of expert advice often pays for itself in a deal of this magnitude by securing better terms and avoiding pitfalls.
By following these recommendations, enterprises can approach SAP Private Cloud with a clear strategy, capturing its benefits of simplicity and innovation enablement, while mitigating the financial and contractual risks that come with a bundled cloud offering.
Read about our Rise with SAP Advisory Service.
