SAP Negotiation Strategies

Negotiating with SAP requires strategy and preparation to achieve the best value and flexibility.

By understanding SAP’s complex licensing models and aligning your contract to your business needs, you can reduce costs, secure higher discounts, and mitigate risks.

This article provides practical strategies for enterprises to negotiate SAP contracts effectively, from preparation and timing to key contract terms, pricing tactics, support, and compliance considerations.

Preparing for an SAP renewal, RISE with SAP proposal, or S/4HANA deal?
This free white paper reveals 10 proven strategies to:

– Reduce costs
– Avoid vendor lock-in
– Strengthen your negotiation position

Designed for CIOs and procurement leaders. Download now and take back control.

Understand Your SAP Licensing and Needs

Successful SAP contract negotiation starts with a clear picture of what you need and how SAP licenses its software.

Overbuying licenses or services (“shelfware”) is a common pitfall, so begin by assessing your current usage and future requirements.

SAP offers a range of license types and deployment models (from traditional on-premise perpetual licenses with annual maintenance to cloud subscriptions like RISE with SAP). Make sure you:

• Assess current and future usage: Conduct an internal audit to determine the number of users and which modules are actually in use. Identify unused licenses or underutilized subscriptions that you’re paying for. This prevents paying maintenance on software you don’t need and informs how many licenses to negotiate going forward.
• Know SAP’s licensing model: Understand the metrics that apply to your SAP products. For example, SAP Named User licenses are assigned per individual (with categories like Professional, Limited, Employee Self-Service, etc.). In contrast, package (engine) licenses are based on metrics like revenue, orders, or CPU cores. Cloud products might use a subscription metric (like Full User Equivalents in S/4HANA Cloud). Knowing these details helps you tailor the contract to the right license mix and avoid ambiguity.
• Growth plan (but avoid overcommitment): Outline your 3-5 year roadmap with SAP. If you expect to roll out new modules (e.g., adding SAP SuccessFactors next year), bring it into the negotiation now to leverage bundling discounts, instead of signing a separate deal later. However, do not purchase far more licenses than needed early on—negotiate the right to add users or capacity later at the same discounted rate to avoid buying “too much, too soon.”

Real-world example: A company might discover through a license audit that 15% of its SAP users are inactive or have higher-level licenses than necessary.

Before renewing, they reclassify or terminate those licenses, saving significantly on support costs.

By understanding SAP’s license definitions and matching users to the appropriate license type, they avoid wasting money on Professional licenses for users who only need a limited scope.

Read SAP Cloud Negotiations: New and Renewal Contracts.

Research Pricing Benchmarks and Leverage

Go into negotiations armed with data. SAP’s list prices are typically not what customers pay – significant discounts are the norm, especially for large deals.

Research industry benchmarks for SAP pricing in your region and industry:

• Typical discounts: For major new software purchases, enterprises often negotiate anywhere from 30% to over 60% off SAP’s list prices. For example, a large SAP S/4HANA license deal could see a 50%+ discount off list if you have volume and leverage. Knowing this helps you set a realistic target price. Aim high in your initial ask – it’s easier to come down than negotiate up from a timid offer.
• Peer benchmarks: If possible, gather anonymous data or consulting insights on what similar companies (size and industry) have achieved in discounts and terms. This gives you confidence that your deal is “at or better than market”. In SAP negotiations, not doing a price benchmark analysis can leave money on the table.
• Leverage alternatives (tactfully): Even if you plan to stick with SAP, having credible alternatives increases your bargaining power. You don’t need to mention competitors by name if you wish to keep it general, but signal that you are evaluating other solutions or approaches. SAP sales reps are aware that customers have choices (whether a different vendor or delaying a project). Letting SAP know that you are willing to consider other options or defer the purchase puts pressure on them to sharpen their offer. Be factual rather than threatening – for instance, indicate you have budget constraints or board-level scrutiny, comparing the SAP proposal with other investments.
• Cross-functional team input: Engage finance and procurement experts who can model the total cost of ownership, and technical experts who understand how licensing metrics translate to usage. Being well-informed about technical and commercial details makes it harder for SAP to upsell unnecessary components or hide costs.

Negotiation leverage varies by scenario. The table below shows how your potential discount and strategy might differ based on what you’re negotiating:

As seen above, initial deals and big expansions yield the highest negotiation leverage – SAP will often give deep one-time discounts to win or grow your business.

In contrast, annual support renewals are harder to reduce (SAP’s business model relies on that 22% maintenance stream).

However, you can still optimize by cutting out shelfware or negotiating multi-year support agreements for stability.

Always analyze the deal in context and set your expectations accordingly.

Time Your Negotiations and Bundle Wisely

Timing can significantly influence the outcome of an SAP negotiation. SAP, like many vendors, operates on quarterly and annual sales targets.

The end of Q4 (calendar year-end, since SAP’s fiscal year ends in December) is typically when sales teams are under the most pressure to close deals.

Use this to your advantage:

• Leverage quarter-end urgency: Plan your purchasing cycle so that negotiations climax as SAP approaches its end-of-quarter or end-of-year. In the final weeks of a quarter (especially Q4), SAP may offer extra incentives or a better discount to hit their quota. For example, a deal that seemed stagnant might suddenly get approved for an additional 10-15% discount in late December. Be prepared to move quickly if you choose this timing – SAP’s urgency can be your opportunity, but don’t let the rush force you into skipping proper review of terms.
• Bundle multiple needs into one deal: Rather than negotiating piecemeal for software throughout the year, consolidate your SAP requirements into a single negotiation if possible. A larger deal size puts you in a higher discount tier. For instance, combining an ERP upgrade license purchase with additional analytics or HR modules in one contract can justify a bigger overall discount. Bundling can also include multi-country or multi-division purchases together. However, be careful not to bundle things you don’t need just for a notional discount – you’ll end up paying for shelfware. Bundle smartly: include items you genuinely plan to use in the near term.
• Be willing to walk away or wait: If a deal isn’t meeting your targets by year-end, consider letting it slip into the new year and revisiting it. Sometimes the best leverage is the ability to say “no” or delay the purchase. You may find SAP returns in the new quarter with a better offer rather than losing the sale entirely. Ensure management is aligned on this strategy so that you’re not internally pressured to accept a subpar deal just because of a deadline.

One strategy is to use SAP’s sales incentives to mutual advantage. If SAP is heavily pushing a new product or cloud offering this year, showing interest in that product as part of your deal (even if it’s a small pilot purchase) can unlock extra discounts or funding.

For example, if SAP is promoting its cloud platform or RISE bundle, they might offer you attractive terms on those if you include them, which can spill over into better pricing on your main items. Always weigh the benefit of any “promo” add-on against its real value to you.

Negotiate Key Contract Terms (Not Just Price)

Focusing only on the up-front price is a common mistake in SAP negotiations. Equally important are the contract terms that govern future costs and flexibility.

Insist on clauses that protect you over the long run:

• Price protection and caps: If you’re signing a multi-year deal or subscription, negotiate limits on future price increases. For cloud subscriptions, this means capping the annual renewal increase (e.g., no more than 5% increase at renewal). Without a cap, you might face a steep price hike after the initial term. For on-premises licenses, SAP’s standard support fee is 22% of your license cost – ensure this is calculated on your net (discounted) license price and try to lock that percentage. Avoid clauses that allow SAP to increase maintenance percentages or list prices arbitrarily over time (some contracts have had built-in 5-10% annual list price escalators, which you want to strike out).
• Additional purchase rights: Secure the option to buy additional licenses or users later at the same discount or fixed price as the initial deal. This way, if your organization grows, you won’t be forced to renegotiate from scratch (where SAP could charge higher rates). For example, if you buy 500 user licenses now at a 50% discount, negotiate a clause that any extra users added in the next 2 years will get the 50% discount as well.
• Flexibility to swap or optimize licenses: Business needs change, and your contract should allow some flexibility. You might negotiate rights to exchange a certain number of licenses for different types or products of equal value. A classic case is during an SAP S/4HANA migration – you may ask to convert legacy ERP licenses into S/4HANA licenses via credits. Ensure any such conversion or exchange terms (sometimes called license migration or conversion credits) are documented to avoid paying twice for similar functionality.
• Audit and compliance terms: SAP’s standard contracts allow license audits, but you can negotiate the frequency and process. Aim to include a clause that SAP cannot audit more than, say, once per year and must give reasonable notice. Define how indirect access usage will be counted or capped to prevent surprise bills (for instance, if you adopt SAP’s Digital Access model, maybe negotiate a certain number of documents included or a discount on excess usage). Clear audit terms protect you from aggressive compliance enforcement and set a cooperative tone.
• Termination and downgrade rights: In long-term agreements, try to include “escape” hatches or flexibility. For cloud deals, negotiate termination rights or penalties that aren’t overly punitive if SAP fails to meet service levels. In some cases, customers negotiate a one-time ability to reduce users or switch out a cloud module at renewal if business demand falls. While SAP may not always agree, even a small concession here (like the right to reduce subscriptions by 10% at renewal without penalty) can save money if your situation changes.

Always involve your legal team to review SAP’s contract language on liability, data protection, and warranties.

Don’t assume any term is “standard and non-negotiable” – while SAP has standard contracts, many large customers successfully negotiate modifications to terms like audit rights, price locks, and special conditions.

The key is to ask clearly and back it up with reasoning (for example, “we need X clause because our policy/board requires Y”).

Optimize Maintenance and Support Costs

SAP support and maintenance fees consume a large part of IT budgets, and they often increase over time.

A smart negotiation strategy looks at reducing ongoing costs, not just the upfront license cost:

• Avoid paying for unused support: If you have SAP licenses or subscriptions that are no longer used (for example, a module you implemented and then retired), you might be paying maintenance or subscription fees for nothing. Identify this shelfware and remove it from your renewals. SAP typically doesn’t let you reduce your maintenance on a whim (without also terminating the licenses), but you can plan a contract exit for those unused components. In some cases, you can negotiate to apply the value of unused licenses as credit toward new purchases (so you’re not double-paying).
• Right-size support level: SAP offers different support tiers (Standard, Enterprise Support, Product Support for Large Enterprises, etc.). Don’t automatically pay for the highest level if you don’t need it across the board. If certain systems are non-critical, a lower support level or even third-party support could suffice and save money. Third-party support providers (outside SAP) can sometimes support older SAP systems at half the maintenance cost – just the possibility of switching can be a negotiation lever with SAP. If sticking with SAP support, ensure the service level agreements (SLAs) in the contract meet your needs; negotiate better SLAs or credits for downtime if necessary, especially for cloud services.
• Be mindful of support fee increases: SAP has periodically raised support fees (for example, in recent years, SAP announced increases of a few percentage points due to inflation). Negotiate a cap on maintenance fee increases if possible, or at least be aware and budget for these if they’re baked into contract terms. One tactic is to negotiate a multi-year maintenance fee lock or a gradual reduction if you commit to a longer support term. While SAP’s standard policy is fixed (e.g., 22% of net license price), any custom agreements should explicitly state the percentage and that it won’t increase for the duration of your contract.
• Total Cost of Ownership focus: During negotiation, consider asking SAP for additional value-adds that reduce your cost of ownership. This might include a certain number of free training seats, some included consulting days for deployment, or tools to help with license management. These can offset costs you’d otherwise bear and sweeten the deal without affecting license pricing directly.

Also, remember timing for support: if you are nearing the end of a fiscal year, SAP might be more amenable to discounting one-time support fees (like a support reinstatement or an extension) to hit their number. Use that to negotiate any support-related concessions at the same time as licenses.

Mitigate Compliance and Indirect Access Risks

A major cost exposure with SAP can come from compliance issues, notably indirect access.

Indirect access means using SAP data via third-party applications or interfaces without a proper license, and it has led to high-profile disputes where customers faced hefty fees.

To protect your organization:

• Clarify indirect usage terms: Discuss indirect access upfront in the negotiation. SAP introduced a Digital Access licensing model that charges based on documents (e.g. sales orders) created indirectly. If this affects you, negotiate a reasonable document quota or a discount for the digital access licenses. In some cases, SAP has offered initial free document licenses or discounts to encourage adoption of the new model. Make sure your contract reflects whichever model (user-based or document-based) you choose, and that you won’t be double-charged.
• Audit self-assessment and resolution: Ensure the contract outlines how audits will be conducted and how potential compliance gaps can be resolved. Ideally, secure the right to remediate issues (buy additional licenses at a pre-agreed discount) rather than facing a full list-price penalty. Some customers negotiate an audit clause where, if a shortfall is found, they can purchase the needed licenses at the same discount as the original order instead of paying back maintenance and penalties on top.
• Stay compliant proactively: Internally, invest in software asset management for SAP. Regularly run SAP’s license measurement tools (LAW scripts, USMM reports) to track usage versus entitlements. If you detect a growing usage trend that might cause non-compliance (say, more users or a higher engine metric than licensed), address it before SAP’s official audit. Coming to the negotiation table with transparency about your usage builds credibility – you can say, “We’ve assessed our needs and we might require X more licenses; let’s incorporate that now with proper terms,” instead of waiting for SAP to catch you out.
• Learn from compliance cases: Big SAP customers have learned the hard way about indirect use. For example, one company in the beverage industry was found to have customer portals indirectly pulling data from SAP without sufficient licenses, resulting in a multi-million dollar dispute. Use such cases as leverage to push for clarity in your contract. If an area of SAP’s license policy is ambiguous (like IoT devices, APIs, etc.), get a written confirmation or contract addendum on how those are handled for your situation.

Fundamentally, compliance risk is a negotiation topic. Don’t treat it as separate – by negotiating clear terms on usage and audits, you reduce the chance of surprise costs later. SAP’s sales team might not bring it up proactively, so you need to.

Leverage SAP’s Strategic Initiatives

SAP’s current strategic pushes can create negotiation opportunities for you. Two major trends are the push to move customers to SAP S/4HANA (next-gen ERP) and cloud subscription models like RISE with SAP.

If your organization is considering these:

• S/4HANA migration deals: SAP is eager for its ECC (old ERP) customers to transition to S/4HANA. This gives you leverage to ask for conversion incentives. Negotiate a favorable conversion program – for instance, trade in your existing ERP user licenses for S/4HANA licenses with minimal or no net cost. SAP often has offers like conversion credits or bundling of transformation tools. Also, since moving to S/4HANA can be costly, push for discounts on the new licenses or subscription, citing the long-term commitment you’re making. Customers who negotiate during an S/4 migration often secure better-than-usual discounts and even funding for migration services or training.
• RISE with SAP and cloud transitions: RISE with SAP bundles software, infrastructure, and support into one subscription. If this model suits you, know that SAP’s pricing there can be opaque. Negotiate the RISE deal as you would any large cloud deal: ensure the cost per user (or per FUE) is competitive and seek contractual flexibility (for example, the ability to scale down if needed after a certain period, or clarity on who bears costs of cloud infrastructure increases). Because RISE is strategic for SAP, you may get extra incentives, like a percentage of free cloud credits, extended trial periods for other cloud services, or favorable payment terms. Use that to your advantage, but also scrutinize the fine print (like data center locations, SLA commitments, and what exactly is included or not).
• Be a reference for rewards: If you’re embracing one of SAP’s new initiatives (like being an early adopter of a new cloud module), SAP might offer additional discounts or perks if you agree to be a reference customer or success story. This can be a win-win: you get a better deal, and SAP gets a case study. Only agree to this if you’re comfortable; otherwise, you can offer softer concessions like participating in SAP advisory councils in exchange for pricing consideration.

Remember, SAP’s strategic objectives (cloud adoption, competing with rivals in certain domains, pushing new products) can align with your negotiation if you position your deal in a way that helps SAP achieve its goals.

In return, ask for something that helps your goals, whether it’s lower cost, better terms, or extra services.

Recommendations

• Do your homework before negotiating: Inventory your current SAP licenses, usage levels, and future needs. Go in with a clear view of what you truly need and what you can cut.
• Set target outcomes and walk-away terms: Define your ideal discount, budget limit, and must-have clauses (e.g., price caps, swap rights). Also, decide on deal-breakers in advance.
• Leverage timing and bundling: Whenever possible, coordinate major negotiations with SAP’s fiscal calendar end and bundle your requirements to maximize discount leverage.
• Insist on flexibility in contracts: Push for terms that let you adjust over time, like the ability to add licenses at locked-in rates, or to remove unused products from maintenance.
• Benchmark and challenge pricing: Use market data or expert advisors to benchmark SAP’s offer. If a proposal seems high, challenge it with data and ask SAP to justify how it’s competitive.
• Address “hidden” cost factors: Bring up indirect access, future price increases, support costs, etc., during negotiation – don’t wait until after signing to discover expensive surprises.
• Engage stakeholders and experts: Include procurement specialists, legal counsel, and SAP licensing experts in the process. A cross-functional approach ensures financial, technical, and legal angles are all covered.
• Be prepared to say no: If SAP isn’t meeting your requirements, be ready to pause or explore alternatives. Maintaining credible alternatives (even delaying a project or using another vendor) is often your strongest bargaining chip.
• Document everything: Ensure that all negotiated points (discounts, special terms, future entitlements) are written in the contract or an amendment. Verbal promises from salespeople mean nothing once the contract is signed.
• Plan for the long term: Aim for a win-win outcome where SAP gets a committed customer, and you get a fair deal with protections. This sets the stage for a positive partnership rather than adversarial true-ups later.

FAQ

Q1: How much of a discount can we get off SAP’s list prices?
A: It depends on the deal size and context. For new license purchases or big expansions, discounts of 40–60% off list price are common for enterprise customers, and exceptionally even more. Smaller deals or add-ons might see 20–30%. Maintenance renewals usually see little to no discount (since support is standard at ~22% of license cost), though you might save by cutting unused licenses. Always start negotiations expecting significant discounts – list prices are merely a starting point.

Q2: When is the best time to negotiate an SAP contract?
A: The end of SAP’s fiscal year (Q4, which is late in the calendar year) is often the best time, as SAP’s sales teams are eager to close deals to meet annual targets. End of quarters (March, June, September, December) can also be good leverage points. During these times, you may receive more favorable pricing or concessions. However, ensure you don’t rush due diligence just to hit a date. If a deal isn’t ready by year-end, you can often get a similar offer in Q1 once the crunch has passed (especially if SAP believes you’ll sign soon).

Q3: How can we avoid paying for SAP software we aren’t using (shelfware)?
A: First, regularly audit your SAP user list and product usage. Remove or reassign unused accounts rather than automatically renewing them. Before a renewal or new purchase, compile a list of licenses/modules that are underutilized. You can attempt to negotiate a give-back or swap – for example, dropping 200 unused licenses and maybe buying something else of equivalent value that you do need. At minimum, stop paying maintenance on software you’ve retired by notifying SAP you won’t renew those specific licenses (which typically means you forfeit the right to use those going forward). This optimization ensures you’re only paying for what delivers value.

Q4: What are the key contract clauses to watch out for in SAP agreements?
A: Pay close attention to any terms about price increases (yearly indexation or list price hikes), audit rights, and usage definitions. Make sure the contract clearly defines license metrics (so there’s no ambiguity on what counts as a “user” or a “processor,” etc.). Look for any “automatic renewal” clauses for cloud subscriptions and ensure you have the right to confirm or renegotiate. If you see a clause allowing SAP to charge more in the future under certain conditions (like inflation adjustments or if you exceed some use threshold), negotiate it. Also, review liability, warranty, and data protection clauses with legal. While SAP often won’t remove them, they might soften overly broad audit terms or add language to protect your interests if asked.

Q5: Should we consider third-party support to save on SAP maintenance costs?
A: Third-party support (from providers outside SAP) can reduce annual support fees significantly (sometimes 50% savings), but it comes with trade-offs. You’ll no longer get software updates or direct support from SAP once you leave their maintenance. Some companies use third-party support for older SAP systems they don’t plan to upgrade, using the savings for other projects. Bringing this option to SAP’s attention during negotiation can sometimes lead SAP to offer a better deal (like a temporary maintenance discount or other concessions) to keep your support business. It’s worth evaluating – even if you don’t switch, knowing the third-party option gives you leverage and a benchmark for the value of SAP’s support.

Q6: How do we handle SAP’s indirect access (digital access) issue in negotiations?
A: Acknowledge it early and get it on the table. Ask SAP to explain how indirect usage applies to your environment. If you interface non-SAP systems with SAP, clarify if those interactions require additional licenses. You can negotiate adopting SAP’s Digital Access model, which charges by documents created; if doing so, estimate your document counts and negotiate a sufficient allotment or price per document. Some customers negotiate a one-time conversion where they trade some old user licenses for a block of digital access documents. The key is to avoid an open-ended exposure – you want a defined model (user-based or document-based) in the contract. Also, include a clause that if you inadvertently exceed something, you get to true-up at a predetermined rate instead of being penalized at list price.

Q7: What strategies work best for an SAP S/4HANA migration contract?
A: If you’re upgrading to S/4HANA, leverage SAP’s desire for customers to move to this flagship product. Negotiate conversion credits to avoid losing your investment in past SAP licenses – SAP may allow you to convert legacy licenses to S/4HANA licenses at a minimal cost. Also, because S/4HANA often involves new licensing (maybe a different metric or cloud subscriptions), push for discounted package deals. Many companies have secured special discounts or even free transitional licenses during the migration period (for example, not paying double licenses during an overlap). Ensure the contract covers the transition period and that maintenance on old products is handled fairly if you switch (e.g., you might stop paying for old licenses once you go live on S/4HANA, without penalty).

Q8: Is it better to choose perpetual licenses or cloud subscriptions with SAP?
A: This depends on your business strategy and can also be a negotiation point. Perpetual licenses (on-premises) mean a big upfront cost, but you own the rights indefinitely (paying annual support for updates). Subscriptions (cloud/RISE) spread costs over time, but if you stop paying, you lose access to the software. From a negotiation perspective, SAP is pushing cloud subscriptions, so you might get a better discount or incentives for going that route. However, consider the total 5-10 year cost. If you have stable usage and plan to keep the software long-term without major changes, perpetual might be cheaper in the long run (especially if you later decide to drop maintenance and keep using the older version). If you need flexibility, rapid innovation, or want SAP to handle infrastructure, cloud could be better, despite potentially higher long-term costs. You can also negotiate hybrid models or conversions (for instance, an initial term subscription with an option to convert to on-prem licenses if strategies change).

Q9: How can we improve our negotiation position if SAP is a critical, entrenched vendor for us?
A: When you can’t easily walk away from SAP, focus on creating internal options and leverage points. For example, identify one or two areas where you could use a different solution (maybe a bolt-on analytics tool instead of an SAP module) and let SAP know you’re considering it. Even if SAP is deeply embedded, they fear losing incremental business. Another approach is to use timing and internal approvals as leverage – make SAP aware that any deal needs higher management approval and that those approvers are cost-sensitive and willing to consider drastic measures (like delaying projects or exploring other vendors). Highlight your history as a loyal customer but also the fact that budgets are tight and every expenditure is being justified. Essentially, you want SAP to understand that although you are likely to stay with them, they still have to compete for your spend through value and price, not just assumption. Additionally, cultivate executive relationships (have your CIO/CFO talk to SAP counterparts) to escalate your concerns – SAP is more flexible when they sense a risk of customer dissatisfaction at the executive level.

Q10: What role do SAP’s partners or resellers play in negotiation – can we get a better deal through them?
A: SAP sometimes sells through channel partners or resellers, especially in certain regions or for mid-market deals. In enterprise deals, SAP often handles it directly, but partners can help add value or services. A partner might have some flexibility in how they discount services or bundle their implementation in a proposal. However, the list price and discount on SAP licenses are usually controlled by SAP globally, regardless of who resells. It’s worth getting quotes through an SAP partner if you have one, as they might throw in free services or have lobbying power to get you a better discount from SAP (since they also want to win your services business). Just ensure that any partner involvement doesn’t complicate your negotiation – sometimes adding a middleman means you need to ensure all terms (especially things like price protections or special clauses) are properly passed through. Use partners as allies for market intelligence and negotiating support, but ultimately, the main commercial terms still come down to SAP’s approval.

Read about our SAP Contract Negotiation Service.

Do you want to know more about our SAP Negotiation Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

First

Last

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit