SAP Negotiation Renewal Strategies for Cloud Contracts

SAP Negotiation Renewal Strategies for Cloud Contracts

SAP contract negotiations for cloud products require a proactive strategy and informed tactics.

Whether signing a new SAP cloud contract or renewing an existing one, enterprise IT leaders must focus on cost reduction, pricing transparency, and flexibility.

The key takeaway: With careful planning and leverage, you can contain costs and avoid vendor lock-in while securing favorable terms across RISE with SAP and other cloud offerings.

Preparing for an SAP renewal, RISE with SAP proposal, or S/4HANA deal?
This free white paper reveals 10 proven strategies to:

– Reduce costs
– Avoid vendor lock-in
– Strengthen your negotiation position

Designed for CIOs and procurement leaders. Download now and take back control.

SAP Cloud Licensing Essentials

SAP’s shift to cloud licensing means moving from upfront perpetual licenses to recurring subscriptions.

It’s crucial to understand SAP cloud contract basics before negotiating:

• Subscription Terms: Most SAP cloud agreements run 3–5 years. After the term, you must renew to continue service, often at new rates if not negotiated upfront. Being aware of this lifecycle prevents surprise “sticker shock” at renewal.
• Licensing Metrics: Different SAP cloud products use different usage metrics. SuccessFactors is typically priced per employee, Ariba by spend volume, S/4HANA Cloud (RISE) by a Full User Equivalent (FUE) count, etc. Know how your usage (users, transactions, revenue, etc.) drives costs so you can right-size your contract.
• Built-in Increases: SAP often applies annual price uplifts (commonly around 3–5% per year) on cloud subscriptions. Without negotiation, a $1M subscription can climb to $1.16M+ after three years. Recognizing this standard increase is the baseline for your negotiations – your goal is to minimize or eliminate it through contract terms.

Read SAP Cloud Negotiations: New and Renewal Contracts

Navigating RISE with SAP and Cloud Options

RISE with SAP is a bundled offering that includes S/4HANA Cloud, technical services, and infrastructure in one package.

SAP is aggressively promoting RISE, so use this to your advantage:

• Evaluate Fit: RISE can simplify your move to S/4HANA, but it might not suit every enterprise. It bundles SAP’s cloud platform and support, which can introduce vendor lock-in. Before committing, assess if RISE aligns with your strategy (e.g. do you need SAP-managed infrastructure, or would a more modular approach be cheaper and more flexible?).
• Leverage SAP’s Push: Because SAP is keen on RISE adoption, customers have the leverage to obtain incentives. If RISE is right for you, negotiate hard on price – SAP may offer extra discounts or credits for signing a RISE deal, especially at quarter-end or fiscal year-end.
• Break Down the Bundle: In negotiation, ask for transparency on RISE’s components (software vs. cloud infrastructure vs. services costs). Understanding the cost breakdown lets you identify overpriced elements. For example, if you already have a favorable cloud hosting agreement with a hyperscaler, see if SAP will adjust the RISE price or allow you to bring your own license for infrastructure. Ensure any services in the bundle meet your needs and consider negotiating them out if not needed.
• Plan for Flexibility: RISE contracts should be scrutinized for flexibility. Negotiate terms that allow for scaling users up or down, swapping modules, or adjusting cloud resources during the term. Make sure you have clear exit provisions at contract end (e.g., data extraction rights and a smooth transition if you don’t renew RISE). All these considerations ensure RISE’s convenience doesn’t come at the cost of future agility.

Read SAP Negotiation Mistakes to Avoid.

Negotiating New SAP Cloud Contracts

When engaging in a new SAP cloud deal, preparation and clarity are your allies:

• Internal Requirements First: Before talking to SAP, internally determine your exact needs. Identify which cloud products and how many users (or transactions, etc.) you truly require. This prevents SAP from selling you unneeded extras “just in case.” Being clear on scope also helps avoid shelfware (unused subscriptions).
• Insist on Pricing Transparency: Ask SAP to provide line-item pricing and discount details for each component of the cloud deal. Rather than accepting a single blended discount, see the list price and net price per item (e.g., per module or service). This transparency lets you validate that each piece is competitively priced and not subsidizing another. It also positions you to negotiate high-cost items specifically.
• Benchmark and Compare: Arm yourself with industry benchmarks and even competitor quotes. Knowing what other companies pay for similar SAP cloud services (or alternatives like Oracle Cloud, Workday, etc.) gives you negotiation power. If SAP’s initial quote is above market, confidently push back. SAP sales teams have flexibility, especially if they sense you’re considering other vendors.
• Use Volume and Term to Your Advantage: SAP cloud contracts often have tiered pricing – higher volumes can reduce per-unit costs. If you anticipate growth, negotiate pricing for a higher tier now (or a right to grow into that tier at the same rate). Similarly, a longer contract term (e.g., committing to 5 years instead of 3) might earn better discounts. Just ensure a long-term plan includes protections (like price locks or the ability to adjust down if needed). Always weigh multi-year savings against potential future changes in your business or technology; don’t overcommit for a discount.
• Lock In Renewal Protections Early: For new cloud contracts, try to include caps on renewal increases or even pre-agreed renewal pricing. For example, negotiate a clause that limits any subscription price increase to, say, 3% at renewal. Securing this upfront in a new deal can save you from painful surprises later. Vendors might resist, but if it’s a deal-breaker for you, bring it to the table early. You may trade a slightly lower initial discount for better long-term stability, which is often worth it.

SAP Contract Renewal Strategies

Renewals are when SAP often looks to raise rates or sell more, so approach them as a strategic renegotiation rather than a routine admin step:

• Start Early and Assess Usage: Begin renewal planning 6–12 months before your contract ends. Use that time to do an internal audit of your current SAP usage. Identify unused or under-utilized subscriptions (cloud modules or user licenses you’re not using fully). These are bargaining chips: you can potentially drop them or ask to swap them for more needed products. Coming to SAP with a precise understanding of what you use (and don’t use) positions you to avoid simply renewing everything as-is.
• Expect the Uplift – and Counter It: If your contract has a standard uplift (e.g., support fees climbing 5% or cloud fees jumping after the initial term), challenge it. Vendors often assume customers will accept an automatic increase. Instead, negotiate for a price freeze or minimal increase at renewal. Highlight your loyalty and past spend – a long-time SAP customer should ask, “Can we do better than the generic increase?” Often, SAP will concede to smaller uplifts (or none at all) for strategic customers, especially if they fear losing future business.
• Leverage Upcoming Projects: If you have future initiatives involving SAP, use them in your negotiation. For instance, if you’re considering adding SAP modules (SuccessFactors, Ariba, analytics, etc.) or migrating on-premise systems to the cloud, mention this in renewal talks. It signals potential new revenue for SAP. In exchange, ask for concessions now: perhaps a deeper discount on the renewal or a credit toward that future project. Be realistic – only use this lever if those projects are plausible, but when credible, it’s one of the best ways to get SAP to flex on pricing or terms.
• Consolidate and Co-Term: Many enterprises have multiple SAP cloud products with different end dates. Aligning them (co-terminus dates) can increase your leverage. Instead of small separate renewals, negotiate a larger, combined renewal covering all your SAP products at once. SAP will see a bigger deal and may give more concessions. Plus, it simplifies administration. If aligning isn’t possible immediately, plan to gradually merge contract dates over a few cycles.
• Escalate if Necessary: Don’t hesitate to involve senior leadership on both sides if negotiations stall. SAP account reps might initially say certain discounts or terms “aren’t possible.” Often, higher-level SAP executives can approve special terms, like an extended price lock or additional discounts, especially for significant customers. A CIO-to-SAP executive conversation, emphasizing a long-term partnership, can break impasses. Use executive relationships to underscore how serious you are about getting a fair deal.

Cost Containment and Pricing Tactics

Controlling costs in an SAP agreement is an ongoing effort. Here are tactics to drive cost efficiency:

• Eliminate Shelfware: Regularly review which cloud subscriptions and user licenses are actually in use. If you’re paying for 10,000 SAP user licenses but only 8,000 are active, that’s wasted spend. Going into a negotiation, quantify this and plan to remove or downgrade unused licenses. SAP won’t volunteer to reduce your bill, but if you have the data, you can push to eliminate or swap out unused entitlements.
• Optimize License Types: Ensure each user has the appropriate license type or subscription level. For example, in SuccessFactors or S/4HANA, some users might only need self-service access versus full professional access. Downgrading a cohort of users to a cheaper license tier saves money without impacting functionality. Similarly, confirm you aren’t accidentally licensed for premium support or features that you don’t utilize – if so, consider cutting those costs at renewal.
• Negotiate Volume Flex and Discounts: If you anticipate needing more licenses later, negotiate volume pricing now. For instance, you might not need 500 extra users today, but if there’s a chance in year 2 or 3, negotiate a clause to add users at the original per-user rate (or a predetermined discount). This prevents SAP from charging you a higher rate later when you’re locked in. Additionally, always ask SAP if there’s a better pricing tier you could reach. Sometimes buying slightly more upfront drops the unit price enough to justify it (e.g., pricing breaks at 1,000, 5,000, 10,000 users, etc.). Be careful to only buy what you’ll actually use, but use SAP’s volume discount structure to your benefit.
• Consider Third-Party Support (for Legacy Systems): If you still have some SAP on-premise licenses with hefty maintenance fees, you have an alternative: third-party support providers. Vendors like Rimini Street can support ECC or other legacy SAP systems, often at 50% of SAP’s maintenance cost. Bringing up the option of third-party support in negotiations can pressure SAP to offer a better maintenance discount or incentivize them to give you a deal on moving to the cloud. While this primarily applies to on-prem environments, it’s part of your overall SAP cost strategy – show SAP you have options to reduce spend.
• Competitive Pressure: Even within cloud modules, SAP often has competitors (for example, SAP SuccessFactors vs. Workday for HR, or SAP Analytics Cloud vs. Power BI). Leverage this competition. Obtain quotes or at least demonstrate that you’re evaluating alternatives. SAP will frequently match pricing concessions or improve terms if it knows it’s a competitive situation. The goal isn’t necessarily to switch providers (which can be complex), but to ensure SAP doesn’t overcharge due to complacency. Your negotiation stance should be: “We want the best value, and we’re willing to consider other solutions if needed.”

Ensuring Flexibility and Avoiding Vendor Lock-In

A contract that seems great on day one can become a trap later if it lacks flexibility. Focus on terms that protect you throughout the relationship:

• Renewal and Exit Clauses: Scrutinize how the contract handles end-of-term. Avoid auto-renewals that lock you in for an extra year without a chance to negotiate. Ideally, negotiate for a renewal cap (e.g., pricing can’t increase more than a certain percentage) and require SAP to engage in good-faith renegotiation for the next term. Also, include a clause for data export or transition assistance at the end of the contract, so if you decide to leave SAP or switch to a different model, you can do so without hindrance.
• Swap Rights and Adjustments: The needs of your business will change. Try to include swap rights, allowing you to exchange one SAP product for another of equivalent value. For instance, if you decide to phase out one cloud module in favor of another, you could repurpose those subscription fees to the new product. SAP historically offers swap rights more readily for on-prem licenses, but cloud customers can negotiate similar flexibility at renewal events. Even if you can’t swap mid-term, ensure you can reduce quantities or change the solution mix at renewal without penalty.
• Service Level Agreements (SLAs): Ensure the contract’s SLA commitments align with your operational needs. If an SAP cloud service is mission-critical, negotiate for stronger SLAs or penalties/credits if availability drops below agreed levels. While this doesn’t directly cut costs, it ensures you’re covered in case of issues and forces SAP to maintain service quality (or compensate you). It’s a form of risk mitigation that protects the value of your spend.
• Avoiding One-Sided Terms: Watch out for terms that heavily favor SAP – for example, clauses that allow SAP to adjust pricing with inflation or foreign exchange at will, or strict limits on liability that leave you exposed. Push back on these during negotiation. Aim for reasonable terms: if SAP insists on an inflation adjustment clause, maybe you get the right to review and terminate if the increase is above a threshold. The contract should not handcuff you from making future decisions.
• No Unlimited Indirect Usage Surprises: Ensure the contract clearly defines usage scope to prevent future “indirect use” license claims. In the past, customers faced large bills when third-party systems indirectly accessed SAP data. In a cloud context, clarify that your subscription covers typical integration usage. If SAP’s Digital Access documents model applies (for S/4HANA), negotiate a sensible approach – possibly a fixed fee or a known metric – so you won’t be blindsided by integration-related charges. Clarity here keeps your costs predictable and avoids a form of lock-in by fear.

To summarize these risks and mitigations, consider the following key negotiation focus areas:

By addressing these areas, you build flexibility into your SAP relationship and avoid common traps. The goal is to contain risks and preserve options, so you’re engaging with SAP on your terms, not just theirs.

Recommendations

For enterprise IT sourcing leaders and SAM managers, here are actionable recommendations to drive successful SAP negotiations:

• Begin planning at least a year in advance of any major SAP renewal or new purchase. Early preparation gives you time to audit usage, align stakeholders, and avoid last-minute concessions.
• Establish a clear negotiation mandate internally. Define your must-haves (e.g. price cap, specific discounts, contract terms) and walk-away points. Ensure executive sponsorship so SAP knows your team is united and serious.
• Leverage your full SAP portfolio. Bundle negotiations across all SAP cloud products to increase deal size and bargaining power. Remind SAP of your total spend and long-term commitment when asking for better terms.
• Use data and benchmarks. Come armed with current pricing benchmarks from analyst reports or peer companies. Quantify how much you’re overpaying or could save – hard data on license utilization and market pricing strengthens your case.
• Insist on contract flexibility. Push for terms that let you adjust as needed – whether swapping products, scaling user counts, or terminating elements of the agreement. Flexibility now prevents painful situations later.
• Don’t accept standard uplifts or boilerplate terms. Everything is negotiable if you have leverage. Question any automatic annual increase or unfavorable clause. Even if SAP initially refuses, persist and escalate where needed.
• Create competitive tension. Maintain the credible scenario of moving some workloads to alternative solutions or delaying projects if the terms aren’t acceptable. SAP is more likely to deal when they know you have options.
• Document all agreements. If SAP makes verbal promises (special discounts, future credits, etc.), get them written into the contract. Clear documentation avoids disputes and ensures you actually receive the negotiated benefits.
• Engage expert help if necessary. Consider using third-party advisors or licensing experts who specialize in SAP. They can uncover hidden issues, benchmark deals, and even handle tough negotiations, which can easily pay for themselves in cost savings.
• Maintain a long-term view. Optimize the deal in front of you, but also set the stage for the next one. A well-negotiated contract not only saves money now, it gives you a stronger position when it’s time to renew or expand later.

FAQ

Q: How far in advance should we start preparing for an SAP cloud contract renewal?
A: Ideally, start at least 6–12 months before renewal. Early preparation allows time to audit current usage, form a negotiation strategy, and approach SAP before you’re up against a deadline. If you wait too long, you lose leverage and might be pressured into accepting less favorable terms.

Q: What if SAP is pushing us to adopt RISE with SAP, but we’re not sure if it’s right?
A: Treat SAP’s proposal as just that – a proposal. You are not obliged to accept RISE if it doesn’t fit your needs. Evaluate the costs and benefits of RISE versus other options (like staying on-premises longer or using standalone cloud services). If RISE offers clear advantages, use SAP’s enthusiasm to negotiate a better price and terms (such as flexibility in the contract). If it’s not a good fit, be prepared to say no and negotiate improvements to your current setup or alternative cloud offerings instead.

Q: How can we be sure we’re getting a good price on an SAP cloud deal?
A: Do your homework on pricing. Use industry analysts, user group surveys, or consultants to gather benchmark pricing for similar SAP deals. You can also request SAP to provide volume tier pricing (what would a larger purchase cost per unit?) to gauge if you’re at a fair rate. Don’t hesitate to ask SAP outright if this deal is in line with what similar clients pay – and watch their response. Finally, get a quote from a competitor product if possible; even if you prefer SAP, having that comparison helps validate whether SAP’s price is reasonable or ripe for negotiation.

Q: Can we reduce the number of cloud licenses mid-term if our needs change?
A: SAP’s standard cloud contracts typically don’t allow reducing quantities until renewal. You’re committed for the term you signed up for. However, you can negotiate at renewal to “right-size” downwards with no penalty, especially if you show usage data justifying the reduction. In some cases, if you have a compelling reason (like a business divestiture), you might negotiate a mid-term adjustment. Still, it usually requires giving SAP something (e.g. an extended term or another product purchase). The best approach is to avoid overcommitting upfront and build in flexibility at renewal checkpoints.

Q: What are the most important contract terms to focus on in SAP negotiations?
A: Beyond price, pay close attention to: Renewal terms (cap any price increases and avoid auto-renew traps), Termination clauses (ensure you can exit or decline renewal without penalties, given proper notice), Usage definitions (so you’re clear on what counts as a user, what indirect access is allowed), SLAs and support (make sure service levels meet your needs and you’re not paying extra for support you don’t want), and Liability/indemnity (protect your company in case of major issues). These terms determine your risk exposure and long-term satisfaction as much as the upfront price does. A slightly higher discount means little if the contract’s fine print could cost you more later. Always read SAP’s terms closely and negotiate the ones that could impact your cost or flexibility down the road.

Read about our SAP Contract Negotiation Service.

Do you want to know more about our SAP Negotiation Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

First

Last

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit